Osteria Amici

SuEllen Yoder

3 months ago

We stopped in for a snack and dessert, they had just the right options. A flavorful crab dip and the classic pecan pie. Both were excellent.

Steven Novak

2 months ago

Excellent food and service. The goat cheese bread was a great start! Carne pizza was phenomenal with the red dipping sauce recommend by my server. Unfortunately, I can't remember what it was called. The ribeye pork chop was also great! Will be back next time I am in town.

Randy Cate

5 months ago

Osteria Amici absolutely knocked it out of the park. From the moment we walked in, the service and atmosphere were incredible. Our waitress, Natalie, was fantastic—attentive, friendly, and made the whole experience feel personal and welcoming. The food was next level. The pappardelle was completely off the charts—rich, perfectly cooked, and packed with flavor. The carne pizza was just as impressive with amazing crust and generous toppings. A special shout-out to Ian, the Dean, who clearly runs a great operation and makes you feel like a valued guest. You can tell there’s real pride in the food, the service, and the overall experience. If you’re looking for one of the best dining experiences around, Osteria Amici is a must. We’ll definitely be back.

Hector Candelaria

4 months ago

There are good Italian restaurants… and then there are places that remind you why Italian cuisine is considered an art form. Osteria Amici belongs firmly in the latter category. From the moment you walk through its doors, the experience feels intentional. Not manufactured—intentional. The kind of warmth that can’t be trained into staff, only lived. The kind that greets you at the door and follows you all the way through the evening. Service here moves with a quiet confidence attentive without hovering, polished without pretension and in my case, exemplified perfectly by Lily, whose presence elevated the entire experience. She struck that rare balance of professionalism and genuine kindness, anticipating needs without interrupting moments, and making the night feel personal rather than procedural. And then there is the food. Italian cuisine, at its best, is about balance, restraint, and respect for ingredients. Here, those principles aren’t just followed they’re elevated. Each dish arrives as if it has something to prove, yet nothing to hide. Flavors are layered but never overwhelming, rich yet precise. It’s the kind of meal that doesn’t just satisfy hunger it resets your expectations. You find yourself pausing between bites, not out of fullness, but out of respect. What sets Osteria Amici apart, however, is not just what’s on the plate it’s what happens around it. In an era where restaurants rush you in and out, this establishment does something almost rebellious: it allows moments to breathe. Being welcomed to linger after closing is not just good service it’s a statement. It says that the experience matters more than the turnover, that the evening you’re having is just as important as the food you ordered. That level of care is rare. And unforgettable. In the language of ratings, calling this place a “10 out of 10” feels almost inadequate. Osteria Amici doesn’t simply meet expectations it quietly dismantles them and replaces them with something better. A r

Deniece Schantz

4 months ago

Our recent book club dinner turned into an unexpectedly memorable evening thanks to the incredible staff at this Italian gem. We had gathered to discuss One Italian Summer, but a reservation mix-up initially threatened to derail our plans. Fortunately, the manager stepped in immediately and handled the situation with remarkable grace and efficiency, going above and beyond to accommodate our group and ensure we felt welcomed. Once seated, the experience only improved. Our waitress truly elevated the evening—after learning about our book choice, she took the time to familiarize herself with it and thoughtfully wove in references and insights during her interactions with us. It added such a personal and engaging touch to the night that made our discussion feel even more special. The food was equally impressive. I ordered the Polpo alla Luciana, which was cooked to perfection—tender, flavorful, and beautifully balanced. For dessert, the tiramisu was simply delectable, the ideal sweet finish to a fantastic meal. With its warm ambiance, attentive staff, and delicious cuisine, this restaurant delivered an experience that went far beyond expectations. What could have been a stressful evening turned into one we’ll all be talking about at future book club meetings.

Arlene

5 months ago

Service, food, and cocktails were top notch. We were visiting from out of town and this was one of the better dining experiences I have had. Everyone on staff that night was friendly and welcoming. Shout out to Lilly and the gentleman behind the bar on 3/21! We started with the calamari and octopus. Each of us got a different pasta and we split the tiramisu. All of it was so good and beautifully presented. Thank you for a great dinner and environment to share with friends!

kris heffner

2 months ago

Food was absolutely amazing! Service was impeccable. We had chicken picatta, ragu, chicken Parm and rigatoni al la vodka with meatball. So fresh and worth every bite! I'm from PennsylvaniA but come to Indiana for work a few times a year. We will definitely be back again 😍

Gabby Wright

month ago

We love Amici! This has been our 3rd or 4th time dining with them & we’ve had great experiences every time. Tonight we had Chylee as our server and she was extremely helpful and attentive! Mark (the GM) frequently visited our table to check in with us & was very kind to us throughout our entire meal. He even came outside once we left to take our family photo before leaving the restaurant! Overall, another wonderful experience with Amici & we are excited for our next visit!

Devin Mckaskle

3 months ago

I went on Mother’s Day and it was just a wonderful experience. Only some minor things were kind of not great but wouldn’t stop me from going back. Before we went we looked at the menu over and over and knew what we wanted. Our waiter asked if he could go through the menu and we said oh we’ve been looking at it for awhile and he pretty much said oh well I’m going to anyway.. and did.. and took awhile. I didn’t really like that to be honest. The one thing I really wanted as well was the chicken parm (called something else) and that ran out unfortunately. But other than that it was great. The food was unreal! It was so good!!!! The atmosphere was so good too. We were there late and the sun went down and the lighting was beautiful. And they gave all the mothers a pink rose. It was soo sweet and just made the experience that much better. Don’t hesitate to try this place!

Luis

3 months ago

Honestly one of the best dining experiences I’ve ever had. The atmosphere with the soft jazz music in the background was beautiful and made the entire evening feel relaxing and intimate. I ordered the classic cheese pizza with pepperoni and a side of their Amici sauce, which was divine. The pizza was fluffy, airy, and had a nice crisp to it without anything feeling overpowering. The sauce had a rich flavor blended with cheese that tied everything together perfectly. I also ordered the Toscana Rosso Il Poggione red wine, which was smooth with a slight tartness that balanced it really well. It felt refined without being too heavy. The tiramisu was moist, smooth, and absolutely delicious. Easily one of the best desserts I’ve had, and definitely something you have to try if you visit. The service was top notch. My waitress checked on me often, made great recommendations for both the wine and dessert, and made sure I was taken care of throughout the evening. She even surprised me by covering the tiramisu, which was incredibly kind and genuinely appreciated. Overall, Osteria Amici instantly became one of my favorite restaurants and I’ll absolutely be coming back. Highly recommend giving it a try.